Choosing the Right Leash Walking Tool for Your Dog: Pros and Cons of Each Option

brown lab enrolled in a private dog training board and train program using a collar and dog training leash

Leash training is an essential part of responsible pet ownership and dog training. Not only does it help ensure your dog’s safety, but also helps to create a pleasant walking experience for both you and your pup. But with so many options available, it can be overwhelming to decide which tool is best for your dog.

Below, we’ll break down the most common leash walking tools, their benefits, and potential drawbacks to help you make an informed choice.

Best Leash Options for Training and Walking Your Dog

Dog training collars are designed to assist in reinforcing commands and discouraging unwanted behaviors. However, not all collars work for every dog, and using them correctly is essential to ensure positive training outcomes.

1. Harness

PetSafe Easy Walk No-Pull Dog Harness

Pros:

  • Distributes pressure evenly across the chest and back, reducing strain on the neck.
  • Ideal for small breeds, dogs prone to tracheal collapse, or those with respiratory issues.
  • Great for preventing injuries in strong pullers.

Cons:

  • Can encourage pulling if not used correctly, as some dogs feel more leverage.
  • Not always suitable for leash pressure training.
  • Some designs can restrict shoulder movement, affecting a dog’s gait.

2. Regular Flat Collar

Reflective Dog Collar

Pros:

  • Simple, lightweight, and easy to use for well-trained dogs.
  • Allows for easy ID tag attachment.
  • Generally comfortable for dogs who don’t pull.

Cons:

  • Can cause neck strain or injury in dogs that pull excessively.
  • Offers minimal control for reactive or strong dogs.
  • Not recommended for leash pressure training.

3. Martingale Collar

Martingale Dog Collar

Pros:

  • Designed to tighten slightly when pulled, preventing a dog from slipping out.
  • Safer for dogs with narrow heads, such as Greyhounds.
  • Gentle aversive compared to prong or slip collars.

Cons:

  • Still applies pressure to the neck, which can be problematic for heavy pullers.
  • Offers minimal control for reactive or strong dogs.
  • Requires proper adjustment to avoid excessive tightening.

4. Prong Collar

Herm SPRENGER Ultra-Plus Prong Dog Training Collar, 2.25 mm
Pros:

  • Provides clear and effective communication for leash pressure training.
  • Can be a game-changer for strong pullers when used correctly.
  • Mimics natural correction cues that dogs understand.

Cons:

  • Must be fitted and used properly to avoid discomfort or harm.
  • Misuse or excessive force can lead to negative behavioral associations.
  • May not be suitable for highly sensitive or fearful dogs.

5. Heather’s Heroes Sidekick® (Head Halter)

Get 10% Off (Code: REBECCAPASKO)

Pros:

  • Uses leash pressure training effectively, helping to guide reactive dogs.
  • Provides excellent control with minimal effort.
  • Encourages calm walking behavior by redirecting the head.

Cons:

  • Some dogs hate the collar and find it more aversive than prong collars.
  • Some dogs may resist or paw at the halter initially.
  • Requires proper acclimation and training to be effective.

6. E-Collar

E-collar Technologies

Pros:

  • Allows off-leash reliability while maintaining control.
  • Can be effective for advanced training and recall.
  • Works well for dogs with reactivity or high drive when used properly.

Cons:

  • Requires proper training to avoid misuse.
  • Not a quick fix; should be paired with positive reinforcement.

Which One is Right for Your Dog?

Choosing the right tool depends on your dog’s temperament, training level, and walking behavior. If your dog pulls, a prong collar or head halter may provide better control. For small dogs or those with breathing issues, a harness is a great choice. If you need off-leash reliability, an e-collar can be a valuable tool when used responsibly.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the best leash for a dog that pulls?
A prong collar or head halter (such as Heather’s Heroes Sidekick®) is often the best choice for strong pullers.

Are prong collars safe for dogs?
Yes, when used correctly, prong collars are safe and mimic cues that dogs understand.

How do I stop my dog from pulling on a leash?
Proper leash pressure training, consistency, and using the right walking tool can significantly reduce pulling.

Can I use an e-collar for leash training?
Yes, although E-collars are also suited for off-leash reliability and advanced training.

Final Thoughts

The right leash-walking tool can transform your daily walks, improving communication, reducing frustration, and strengthening your bond with your dog. Make the best choice for your pup and enjoy stress-free walks.

Need Professional Guidance?

If you’re unsure which tool is best for your dog, our professional trainers at Happy With Dogs can help. We offer personalized training sessions in Miami and Southeast Michigan to ensure you and your pup have the best walking experience possible.

We offer personalized virtual lessons tailored to your dog’s needs. Book a FREE virtual consultation today and let us help you resolve reactivity, jumping, and more. Schedule Your Free Consultation

We offer:


Happy Training,

Rebecca and the Happy With Dogs Training Team

This page contains affiliate links. If you choose to purchase after clicking a link, we may receive a commission at no extra cost to you

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share this post

Happy With Dogs Miami

Happy With Dogs Miami

Rebecca was born in Howell, Michigan, and grew up on a livestock farm with 4 siblings and many loving creatures.

Growing up she played rugby and enjoyed showing livestock in 4H, but her passion was for dog training. 

KEEP READING